The Gleaner
News

Court rejects municipalities’ challenge to language law

A ruling by the Quebec Superior Court rejected a bid by 23 bilingual municipalities, including Havelock, to suspend parts of Bill 96 until their challenge to the province’s language law is argued before the court.

The municipalities had argued that four provisions of the law could cause irreparable harm if a stay was not granted. The provisions include those requiring all municipal contracts be written in French; those that allow the province to withhold government subsidies or grants from municipalities that do not comply with Bill 96; those that allow inspectors from the Office québecois de la langue française to search for and seize documents and material without a warrant or notice; and finally, those that require municipalities to discipline employees who fail to respect the language law.

According to a CBC report, the province argued the municipalities did not present concrete evidence of damages from the law. The lawyer representing the province also noted that municipalities fall under provincial jurisdiction, that they do not have constitutional status, and do not need to uphold minority language rights.

Justice Silvana Conte issued her decision on October 15, which dismissed the municipalities claims. In her ruling, she argued the municipalities had not adequately proven that the law will cause serious or irreparable harm. Stays are notoriously difficult to achieve and are only awarded in exceptional cases.

A statement by the city of Côte-Saint-Luc, which is one of the municipalities included in the lawsuit, notes that the judge’s ruling suggests the provisions relating to municipal contracts and the right to search and seize material without a warrant raise serious concerns.

The municipalities have 30 days from the time of the ruling to appeal the decision. (SR)

Latest stories

Police presence increased in Ormstown following fires

Fourth suspicious blaze in Ormstown consumes pizzeria

Sarah Rennie

One person arrested after 4th local pizzeria is attacked

Leave a comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.